Login
Start Free Trial Are you a business? Click Here

The Peanut Butter Cake Reviews

4.7 Rating 64 Reviews
Lorraine Burrows
Verified Reviewer
Can not comment as was sent the wrong cake, received chocolate orange. Birthday cake for my grandson’s birthday today (27th) so didn’t realise until unboxed this afternoon. Very disappointed.
Helpful Report
Posted 2 years ago
Barbara Sams
Verified Reviewer
I bought this cake for my son's birthday. It came on time via courier and I was very impressed with the quality and service. Our son absolutely loved it. He was very surprised and happy at such a lovely cake. I would definitely recommend this company.
Helpful Report
Posted 2 years ago
Stuart McIntosh
Verified Reviewer
Stunning and delicious
Helpful Report
Posted 2 years ago
Samantha Sue Yiollaris
Verified Reviewer
Absolutely delicious. Very happy with delivery and packaging. Will definitely order again
Helpful Report
Posted 2 years ago
Simply delicious!!
Helpful Report
Posted 2 years ago
Sarah J Browne
Verified Reviewer
POSITIVES: Delivery and packaging - Excellent! - Arrived very well packaged Appearance - Amazing! - Lots of Reeses on top Looked impressive lit with candles and the recipient was delighted. Cake texture - Moist NEGATIVES: Very difficult to successfully cut the cake into pieces without using a bit of pressure - Under the top layer it was covered in a hard layer of chocolate. The top was covered with an excessive amount of buttercream and lots of lovely Reeses, hiding the hard chocolate layer - To successfully cut the cake it's probably best to remove some of the Reeses and use a hot knife to cut/melt through the hard layer of chocolate - the recipient was unaware of the hard layer hidden underneath and found the cake very difficult to slice through. The Peanut Butter buttercream is REALLY sweet and tastes more like margarine than butter. The buttercream became very soft and the cake collapsed in the box on the journey home from the restaurant - Needs refrigerating to keep the buttercream in place or the cake will easily collapse. If the cake hadn't easily collapsed I would have recommended The Peanut Butter Cake to peanut butter lovers! An expensive mess now looking very sad sat in the fridge.
Helpful Report
Posted 2 years ago
Elizabeth Pollock
Verified Reviewer
The sponge was sponge was so light, it was not dry the icing was beautiful, my daughter gives it 15/5
Helpful Report
Posted 3 years ago
Sharon Chappell
Verified Reviewer
The cake was delicious and delivered with so much care
Helpful Report
Posted 3 years ago